Friday, April 3, 2009

PALM SUNDAY Rally for Peace Parramatta, 2.00 pm

Amphitheatre at Parramatta Town Hall

2.00pm - Multi-Faith Prayers for Peace

Fr Pat Mullins, priest at Mt Druitt; Exodus Choir

2.30pm - Rally - Dr Sue Wareham, Medical Association for Prevention of War
Sally McManus, Australian Services Union

Sponsored by NSW Ecumenical Council

Organised by Sydney Peace & Justice Coalition

Contact: Bruce Childs 0412 803 457; Fr Claude Mostowik 0411 450 953; Peter Murphy 0418 312 301



No more Australian troops to Afghanistan!

Peace through Dialogue!

Prime Minister Rudd is poised to send up to 5,000 more soldiers to fight in Afghanistan. The Obama Administration is delaying a formal request while public opinion is being gauged in Australia. Over 50 per cent of Australians now oppose the war in Afghanistan. The government needs to answer many questions before possibly increasing its military role there.

The war in Afghanistan is part of a much larger region greatly destablised by the 2003 invasion of Iraq and the subsequent horrific war there. It is also destablised by the convulsion of the Government of Pakistan, also due largely to the huge mistakes of the Bush administration. China, Russia, Iran and India, as well as Pakistan, are neighbours of Afghanistan. All of them, with different interests, will try to influence events in Afghanistan. It appears that the Obama administration is now willing to talk to them about Afghanistan.

Questions that must be answered:

1. If an increase of Australian forces in Oruzgan Province is to replace the Dutch forces withdrawing in 2010, shouldn’t the Prime Minister tell us why the Dutch troops are going, before replacing them?

2. If European members of NATO are unwilling to increase the number of combat troops in Afghanistan, why should Australia do so?

3. Isn’t it true that the Karzai government is negotiating with parts of the Taliban, as is the UK and UN, because they recognize that the war is not working and that a political solution is required?

4. Since neither the British Army nor the Soviet Army could prevail in Afghanistan, shouldn’t the Prime Minister recognize that the US and Australian forces cannot prevail in this military conflict either? Isn’t it more responsible to refuse to go in deeper, to withdraw military forces and promote a political solution?

5. Isn’t the war in Afghanistan degrading Australia’s credibility as a genuine part of the international community, upholding international law, because Australian soldiers are killing civilians including women and children, only to support the general concept of the US Alliance?

6. Since the Bush gang - and the incoming Obama administration - could not define a credible, justifiable strategy for the Afghanistan War, how can Australia justify it? It is no longer credible to claim that the war is to capture Osama bin Laden because of the terror attacks in the USA way back on Sept 11, 2001.

7. While the Taliban is a reactionary political movement which commits atrocities against civilians, isn’t the US aerial bombing – particularly of wedding and funeral processions – killing even more civilians?

8. Isn’t it true that the Taliban are thriving because European Christian troops are taking control of their country? Doesn’t the high civilian casualties only make the Taliban stronger, and destablise Pakistan and India?

9. Isn’t it accurate to see the Afghan government of President Hamid Karzai as a coalition of warlords who also engage in repression, discriminate against women, and are now the world leaders in heroin exports?

10. Wasn’t the Howard policy in Afghanistan part of his subservience to the George W Bush version of US interests? Shouldn’t Australia have an independent approach to foreign policy, even within the US Alliance, especially in the Afghanistan War where Australian soldiers are being killed and wounded?

11. Won’t the outcome in Afghanistan be similar to Viet Nam - another cohort of young Australian men and women with their lives brutalized for nothing, and brutalised communities who call Oruzgan Province ‘home’?

12. Isn’t Australia’s Afghanistan War commitment now costing $575 million per year? Wouldn’t this be better spent on essential public services, the uplift of Aboriginal communities, and on a peaceful Afghanistan?

Sydney Peace & Justice Coalition

Sponsored by: UnionsNSW, Construction Forestry Mining & Energy Union NSW, Aust Manufacturing Workers Union NSW, NSW Teachers Fed, Australian Services Union, Pax Christi, MSC - Peace & Justice, Quakers Peace & Justice, Women’s International League for Peace & Freedom, People for Nuclear Disarmament NSW, Progressive Labour Party, Labor for Refugees, Communist Party of Australia (Marxist Leninist), Evatt Foundation, SEARCH Foundation.

Palm Sunday rally for peace April 5 2009


www.search.org.au
Level 3, 110 Kippax St, Surry Hills, 2010
Ph: 02 9211 4164 Fax: 02 9211 1407
ABN 63 050 096 976

Promoting Democracy, Social Justice and Environmental Sustainability

3 comments:

Anthony said...

I live and work in Afghanistan. I am against all forms of war. Foreign troops in Afghanistan have made many mistakes - civilian deaths not the least. I believe, however, that the removal of all foreigns troops would lead to a far worse situation for the ordinary children, women and men of the country. Whilst ordinary Afghans become annoyed at some of the tactics of the foreign troops, I would estimate that the vast majority would prefer their presence to a return of Taliban rule with all its associated injustices and human rights violations.
How do you negotiate with an totally irrational, unjust and extremely violent aggressor? I am sure I do not know the answer.

Pax Christi Australia NSW said...

Anthony I appreciate your comments this is a vexed question. Your view is valued as you have seen the reality. Maybe the answer might be in sending more peacemaking forces rather than military forces? However I am an idealist! It seems like we as humans only believe in force? We have not worked out well enough what peacemaking forces might be able to do. Maybe we should start there has been legislation presented I believe to the government for creating a ministry of Peace.However I am not sure where this is up to. I hate to think what the reality is really like for the people of Afghanistan my heart grieves for them. No matter who they are. Peace Maggie

Pax Christi Australia NSW said...

Anthony the next issue of Disarming Times will have an article about Afghanistan from a person who has lived there and has knowledge of the people and the place well worth a read. Pace Maggie